For a tank-style heater, installed, the guides we read give $1,000 to $2,700 for gas (Fixr, updated January 30, 2026) and $800 to $1,500 for electric (Fixr, updated January 27, 2026). This Old House's 2026 guide lists tank models at $1,200 to $2,300. No guide separates out a 50-gallon price, so read these as the band a 50-gallon job falls within. The written quote sets the price. The water heater page and the home page have more.
What does replacing a 50 gallon water heater cost?
The installed price should fall inside the tank ranges above: about $1,000 to $2,700 for gas, $800 to $1,500 for electric, and $1,200 to $2,300 in the all-fuel tank range from This Old House. Fixr's average for an installed gas tank is $1,900. All are national guide figures, not Riverside rates, and not what we charge.
Your spot inside the band depends on the unit's brand and efficiency, whether the heater stands in a garage or an attic, and how much the plumber must alter to meet code. Replacing a 50-gallon unit in place lands low in the band. Relocating it, adding a vent or fixing the gas line pushes the price up. Compare quotes line by line, not by total.
Does a 50 gallon tank suit my house?
For many households it does. Makers publish a first-hour rating, the amount of hot water a unit delivers in a busy hour, and sizing should begin with that number and your household's use. A home where several people shower in the morning while a dishwasher runs needs more than a two-adult home.
Have the plumber consider how many bathrooms run simultaneously. A tank that has served well for years makes the same size the safe choice. After adding a soaking tub or growing the family, a larger tank or a tankless unit might suit better. The options are laid out on the page about tank versus tankless heaters.
Is the installed cost different for gas and electric?
Yes. Per the 2026 Fixr guides, electric tank installs cost $800 to $1,500 and gas tank installs $1,000 to $2,700, so electric appears cheaper up front. Gas runs higher to install because of the vent, the gas connection and a flue built to code. Monthly running cost, however, follows local gas and electric rates, not the install price.
SoCalGas lists Riverside, Moreno Valley and Loma Linda among the cities it serves, so most homes already have gas. Moving a gas house to electric can require a new circuit, and moving an electric house to gas requires a new gas line and a vent, and each adds to the quote. Keeping the same fuel is cheapest. For a gas conversion, read gas tankless water heater installation.
What belongs in a 50 gallon quote?
A full quote lists the unit's make, model and warranty, labor, new flexible connectors and a shutoff valve, the gas or electrical connection, venting for gas units, a drain or pan if needed, a permit, earthquake strapping, an expansion tank where the plumber sees a need, and removal of the old tank. Items left out tend to turn up later as extras.
State law has water heaters strapped against earthquakes, so strapping belongs in every quote. A closed system often needs an expansion tank, which the plumber decides on site. In the City of Riverside a replacement generally needs a permit, with the building counter at (951) 826-5800; water heaters do not appear on the city's exempt-work handout. Moreno Valley's number is (951) 413-3350, and Loma Linda's is (909) 799-2836.
What lifespan can a 50 gallon tank reach, and does water quality play a role?
Lifespan shifts with the water and the care a heater gets, and a plumber can judge your unit's age and the wear it shows. Hard water builds mineral scale faster, which insulates the burner or elements from the water and shortens the tank's life. The 2025 Riverside Public Utilities report gives average hardness of 197 mg/L, around 12 grains per gallon.
Regular flushing and a check of the anode rod can extend its life. Anode rod replacement covers the part that keeps the tank from rusting. An old heater that leaks usually needs replacing, and the water heater leak page explains how to tell.
Where do I see the full spread of replacement prices?
The general page on water heater replacement cost puts electric, gas, tankless and heat pump options in one table, and tankless water heater installation cost details that type. The related services are collected on the plumber for water heater replacement page.
Common questions
What is the usual time for a 50 gallon water heater replacement?
Which questions come before hiring a water heater installer?
Must I be home during a water heater replacement?
Does a 50 gallon tank take more floor space than a 40 gallon?
Sources used
- Fixr, How Much Does a Gas Water Heater Cost in 2026?, updated January 30, 2026
- Fixr, Electric Water Heater Installation Cost in 2026, updated January 27, 2026
- This Old House, How Much Does Water Heater Installation Cost? (2026), updated 06/17/2026
- City of Riverside, Work Exempt From Building Permits handout
- Riverside Public Utilities, 2025 Water Quality Report
Page updated