Two handles mean two separate valves, so only one side is usually the culprit. The repair is to turn the water off, dismantle the leaking handle, swap the worn washer, O-ring, seat or cartridge for a new one, and reassemble. If you are at the kitchen sink and the cabinet below also holds a disposal, it helps to know what else sits there, and garbage disposal repair help covers the other fixtures under the sink. A plumber is one request away from our quote page.
Why does a two handle faucet leak?
Inside each handle is a valve that stops the water when you close it. In a compression valve a rubber washer is pushed down against a metal seat, and wear on either lets water slip by. A cartridge or ceramic disc valve uses a sealed insert, and a cracked seal or worn disc leaks the same way.
Where the water shows tells you what failed. A drip at the spout means a worn washer, seat or cartridge. Seepage near the foot of the handle or the stem means an O-ring or packing nut. Water under the sink points to supply lines, connectors or the drain, not the faucet body.
Hard water speeds the wear. Riverside Public Utilities' 2025 water quality report lists hardness averaging 197 mg/L (about 12 grains per gallon), and the mineral scale eats into rubber seats and roughens metal ones. That can be one reason a washer wears out sooner in hard water.
Which tools and parts should I have ready?
You will need an adjustable wrench, a screwdriver, a small flat pry tool for the handle cap, replacement parts that match the faucet, plumber's grease and a rag. Put a towel in the sink to catch dropped screws and close the drain. Take photos of each step so you can reassemble in order.
The parts depend on the faucet. Washers, seats and O-rings are sold in assortment packs, but a cartridge must match the model exactly. Look for a brand name on the faucet or under the handle, or bring the old part with you to a hardware store. If you cannot identify the faucet, a plumber can do it from a photo.
How do I replace a washer or seat in a compression faucet?
With the water off, pop the decorative cap from the handle, remove the retaining screw, then raise the handle off. Unscrew the packing nut with a wrench, pull the stem out, and put a new rubber washer on its end. Look over the seat within the faucet body. A rough or pitted seat should be resurfaced or replaced.
A few details save time:
- Note the order of parts on the stem as you take them off.
- Replace the O-ring on the stem at the same time as the washer, because it costs little and fails next.
- Coat the new O-ring with plumber's grease.
- If the seat is worn, a seat wrench removes it. A new seat is a small part, and a reseating tool can smooth a lightly worn one.
- Reassemble in reverse order, open the supply valve slowly and check for drips at the stem and spout.
Do not overtighten the packing nut. Tighten until the handle turns smoothly without leaking, and add just a small extra turn if water still seeps around the stem.
At what point is a new faucet better than a repair?
Replace the faucet when the body is corroded, the finish is flaking, parts are no longer made for the model or you have repaired the same faucet more than once. A cheap faucet with a worn body may cost more in repair visits than a new one. A plumber can say which side of that line yours is on.
Other signs: a handle that wobbles, a spout leaking where it meets the deck, green or white crust on the fittings, and water that runs even with both handles closed hard. Those usually mean the body or deck seals have failed.
For other faucet types, see fixing a leaky sink faucet, a single handle faucet and the general leaky faucet guide. If the leak is below the sink, see repairing a leaking pipe under the sink.
How do I fix a cartridge or ceramic disc two handle faucet?
Cartridge faucets use a sealed insert. After removing the handle and any retaining clip or nut, pull the cartridge straight out, bring it to a store to match it, and install the new one with the notch aligned. Replace the O-rings on the cartridge body too, and grease them before assembly.
Ceramic disc valves are a quarter-turn style with two ceramic plates sealed by rubber gaskets. If one leaks, check the neoprene seals at the bottom of the cartridge, and clean any mineral deposits from the openings. A new cartridge is easier than trying to repair a cracked disc.
If you pull the cartridge and the faucet body looks corroded around the opening, replacement of the whole faucet may make more sense. Prices for installing a faucet are on faucet installation cost.
Is a dripping faucet worth fixing?
Yes. A drip wastes water and adds up on the bill. The EPA says the average household's leaks waste more than 9,300 gallons of water a year, and its leak guidance lists dripping faucets among the common household leaks. A washer and an hour of time is cheap by comparison, as the next guide on bills explains.
Read whether a leaky faucet raises the water bill for how to measure it. If you are not comfortable with the repair, or the faucet is a kitchen model tied to a disposal and dishwasher connection, ask for a plumber.
Faucet and toilet replacement are listed as exempt from permits in the City of Riverside's handout. That does not cover piping inside walls, which needs a permit, so keep the work at the faucet.
We arrange work in Riverside, Moreno Valley and Loma Linda. The home page shows what other plumbing help is available.
How do I tell which handle is leaking?
Close the supply valves beneath the sink one at a time, starting with the cold valve, and watch the spout. If the drip stops, the cold side is leaking, and if it keeps going, close the hot valve and check again. The valve that stops the drip when closed is the one that feeds the leaking handle.
With both supply valves closed, open the faucet so the lines drain before you take anything apart. If the valves under the sink will not close or are stiff and corroded, shut off the main water supply instead. Seized shutoffs can turn up in older houses, and forcing one can start a leak you did not have.
Common questions
Can I fix a leaking faucet without turning off the water?
Why is the faucet dripping even though I replaced the washer?
How do I know whether my faucet uses washers or cartridges?
Who can fix a faucet in Riverside, Moreno Valley or Loma Linda?
Sources used
Page updated